impact
  • Home
    • About impact >
      • impact in a nutshell >
        • impact's origin story >
          • bio: Kathy Kaplan OAM
        • What else does impact do? >
          • Advocacy & awareness raising
          • Interest-free loans
          • Grants to Refuges
          • Bursaries
          • impactFUL launch party
          • Childcare at Moorabbin Court
      • Our Board >
        • Our vision, mission & values
        • Our policies >
          • Constitution
          • COVID-SAFE measures
          • Acknowledgement of Country
          • Privacy Policy
          • Inclusion Policy
          • Volunteer Policy
          • Child Safety Policy
        • AGM 2022
        • Last year's achievements
        • Board Only Section
    • What is Family Violence?
    • Myth Busting
    • Upcoming events
  • Ways to Help
    • How YOU can help
    • Messages of Hope
    • Donate your dollars
    • Donate your time, effort & skills
    • Bags of Love >
      • Bags of Love - how to help
      • Bags of Love - what to give
    • Trees of Love
    • Court Childcare Project
    • Give them a meal
    • Purses with Purpose
    • Become a sponsor >
      • Sponsor financially
      • Sponsor in kind
  • Get help
    • if your friend needs help
    • Who you can turn to
    • Create a safety plan
    • Tips to help a friend >
      • Helpful things to say, ask or do
      • Things NOT to say, ask or do
    • Tips for youth
    • Tips for male victims
    • Tips for LGBTIQ victims
    • Tips for older people
    • Tips if you witness violence
    • Stay safe online >
      • Conduct an online safety audit
      • Create a strong password
      • Mobile phone safety
      • Computer & internet safety
      • Online banking safety
      • Clear your devices' history
      • Disable tracking devices
  • Get involved
    • Become a Member
    • Volunteer >
      • Coffee Lunch & Craft Group
  • Facts & Stats
    • What is Family Violence?
    • Australia's great shame: the facts >
      • Australia's death toll: 2022
      • Australia's death toll: 2021
      • Australia's death toll: 2020
      • Australia's death toll: 2019
      • Australia's death toll: 2018
    • Cycle of Abuse
    • Warning signs
    • Gaslighting
    • Royal Commission into Family Violence
    • National Community Attitudes Survey
  • Articles, Blogs & Personal Stories
    • News Articles & Blogs
    • Personal Stories
  • Contact us
  • xmas 2020 video
  • Annual Report 2022
  • W&P video 2022
  • PJV chanukah 2006

Parliamentary inquiry into family law will be critical, insists committee head Sarah Henderson

23/8/2017

0 Comments

 
A committee investigating the failings of the family law system will still be critical of the sector despite not calling senior judges to give evidence, according to the head of the inquiry.
Key points:
  • Parliamentary inquiry into failings in family law system will not call judges to give evidence
  • Inquiry chair Sarah Henderson says despite this, the report will be critical of the system
  • Deputy chair Sharon Claydon argues inquiry will be hampered without the judges' evidence
Liberal MP Sarah Henderson had been criticised by Opposition members of the committee for cancelling a scheduled appearance by the Chief Justice of the Family Court and the Chief Judge of the Federal Circuit Court hours before they were due to give evidence.
Ms Henderson argued she wanted to seek the expert advice of Attorney-General George Brandis on whether the judges giving evidence in person would breach the principle of separation of powers, which protects the independence of the judiciary from the influence of parliament.
Deputy Chair of the Committee, Labor MP Sharon Claydon, said the efficacy of the inquiry would be hampered without the judges' evidence, and argued the judges were "highly competent" and able to decide what was appropriate to tell the committee.

But Ms Henderson told the ABC's AM: "I was concerned, and I think it was very prudent and appropriate...that subjecting judges to questioning and interrogation by members of parliament crossed the very important principle of separation of powers.
"We referred this to the Attorney-General, the Attorney-General agreed that this is a fundamental tenet of our democracy.
"I didn't think it was appropriate to put judges in a place where they could be subverted to the harassment or the interrogation of members of parliament."
The judges will still make submissions to the committee in writing.
Ms Claydon led the criticism of Ms Henderson, arguing that the judges had given evidence before parliamentary committees before.
"What we can't do is undermine the judiciary, and that's probably something maybe the deputy chair doesn't quite understand," Ms Henderson said.
"While judges have appeared before parliamentary committees before, what the Attorney has done is drawn a distinction between judges appearing privately and in relation to the operation and decisions of the courts over which they preside.
"I have no doubt that our inquiry will be quite critical in parts about some of the decisions and processes in the Family Court."
Major reform needed in family law systemThe inquiry is hearing evidence in Alice Springs, where Ms Henderson said some of the failings of the family law system were most keenly felt.
They include serious delays in the court processes and the significant expense of hiring lawyers.

"Too often, family violence is not being ascertained early enough in proceedings and that's having major impact on orders made by the court, particularly in relation to children and the safety of children," Ms Henderson said.
"The Northern Territory Government says Aboriginal women are 40 times more likely to be hospitalised as a result of violent assault, most committed by partners or ex-partners as a result of alcohol.
"The rates of non-disclosure are also very high."
Ms Henderson argued some of the people brought in to compile reports on the parlous state of some families were gouging the system.
"Some of them are charging up to $9,000 a day, it's absolutely outrageous," she said.
"Courts rely on family report writers to determine many of the factual matters between warring parents, and particularly involving children.
"I cannot believe the Family Court hasn't addressed this matter — they're not accredited, they're not trained."
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    September 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016

EVERY DOLLAR MAKES A DIFFERENCE
Picture


impact acknowledges the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People as the First Peoples of Australia, the traditional owners of the lands and waters throughout Australia: lands and waters which have never been ceded.
​We recognise their continuing connection to land, waters and community and we pay our respects to their peoples, their cultures, their languages and to their elders past, present and emerging.

​
View impact's Privacy Policy here

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture


​impact is very proud to call the following organisations our key partners:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
ABN: 17 159 728 753
PO BOX 217 GLEN HUNTLY 3163

Copyright © 2022